How to reply to plastic surgery reviews without breaking HIPAA

Plastic Surgery Practice Marketing. Updated November 20, 2026.

Replying to reviews helps your reputation and your Google ranking. For a plastic surgery with a surgeons, it also carries privacy risk. Here is how to do it safely.

Why this matters

If your plastic surgery is a HIPAA covered entity, confirming in public that someone is your patient, or mentioning their procedure, can be a disclosure of protected health information, even if the patient mentioned it first. Regulators have acted on exactly this:

Ask your compliance advisor whether HIPAA applies to your practice. Even if it does not, these rules protect patient trust.

The rules

  1. Do not confirm or deny the reviewer is a patient.
  2. Do not mention any procedure, provider notes, results, dates or prices tied to them.
  3. Do not argue facts in public.
  4. Move every complaint offline to a named manager.
  5. Reply within two business days.

Safe templates

Positive review: "Thank you so much for taking the time to share this. Our whole team works hard to make every visit a great experience, and we are glad you took the time to tell others."

Negative review: "Thank you for your feedback. We take every concern seriously. Because we protect everyone's privacy, we cannot discuss details here, but our practice manager would like to talk with you directly. Please call us at [number] and ask for [name]."

Review about price: "Thanks for sharing your thoughts. We are always happy to explain how our pricing works. Please call [number] and our team will walk you through it."

What not to write

What to do about fake or abusive reviews

Flag reviews that break Google's policies (spam, conflicts of interest, offensive content) in your Business Profile. Do not reply with details to prove they are fake.

Getting more reviews the right way

Ask every patient the same way after every visit with your Google review link. Do not offer discounts for reviews and do not ask only happy patients. The FTC's 2024 rule on fake reviews and testimonials restricts incentives tied to positive reviews.

Common questions

Can a plastic surgery thank a patient by name in a review reply?

It is safest not to. Even a first name plus a thank you can confirm someone is a patient. Keep replies general.